
Gap Shots & Gopher Balls
HAVE YOU SEEN THE "SLUTTER"?
By Chris Vining August 27, 2007
The
baseball world needs to take notice, the “Slutter” is here. Boston Red Sox
star closer Jonathan Papelbon, the first closer in Sox history to post two
thirty save seasons, has a new devastating pitch. By mixing a cut fastball
and a slider grip, and changing his release point and angle, Papelbon has
added something completely new to his already devastating arsenal. Papelbon
had already started to use a cut fastball to keep batters off guard; now the
slutter makes him an even more dangerous pitcher. By increasing his
repertoire Papelbon now has three pitches that can be used as an out pitch,
something that separates him from even elite closers like future Hall of
Fame closer Mariano Rivera.
Papelbon is one of only a handful of pitchers that have been able to post
back-to-back thirty plus save seasons in his first two complete major league
seasons. The other members of this elite club haven’t had the most memorable
careers (Billy Koch was effective for several years before losing his stuff,
Kaz Sasaki returned to Japan, and Todd Worrell was an effective closer for
many years before fizzling out before his career should have ended) but
Papelbon is hoping to be the breakout star of that group. With his career as
a starter officially over, Papelbon has embraced and even desired to be a
career closer. Coming up as a pitcher with comparisons to Roger Clemens,
becoming a closer could be viewed as step back, but not for Papelbon. He has
strived to be one of the best closers ever, and Trevor Hoffman should be
prepared to relinquish his all time saves record to Papelbon around 2022.
With the upper eighty mile per hour slutter in his bag of tricks, Papelbon
can now add more life to his fastball that tops out at over ninety-five
miles per hour. Papelbon has experimented with many different pitches in his
young career, and that is something that looks to continue. By this time
next year Papelbon may mix the secretive gyroball and maybe even a
knuckleball into his rotation. On a cross-country flight Papelbon may learn
the secrets of a dominant curveball from Josh Beckett, or maybe even a
sidearm delivery from his brother in the Red Sox minor league system.
Despite his young age and relative inexperience, Papelbon is far from
complacent with this success, as he is always looking to gain an advantage
over the competition. As a two time All-Star the Red Sox may just have the
most dominant closer in baseball for the next decade, a commodity that is a
must for a successful team. When Papelbon enters the game the opponent
better recognize that all the scouting reports in the world may be for
naught: Papelbon might have just developed something new that very day, and
you never know what he might throw at an unsuspecting hitter. All in a days
work for Cinco-Ocho, master of the slutter.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
LESTER IS BASEBALL'S MOST IMPORTANT MAN
By Chris Vining July 26, 2007
Awesome is a word that has become too pedestrian, but there was a truly
awesome pitching performance on Monday. It wasn’t a perfect game, a
twenty-strikeout gem, or even a shutout, but a six-inning quality start (6
innings 5 hits 2 earned runs 6 strikeouts and one important win). What made
this such an impressive game was the man on the mound, Jon Lester. This was
the second year star’s first big league appearance since his career and life
was sidetracked by cancer. Lester was having a stellar rookie year (7-2 with
a 4.76 ERA in fifteen stars) until he was forced to end his season early
last year due to lymphoma.
Lester was a twenty-two year old with his career in
front of him when his season was put on hold and everyday life took over.
After an off-season of cancer treatments, Lester was a question mark for
this season, but he showed his determination to return to the mound. When
spring training started Lester was there, to the surprise of many people.
While he might not have been completely ready to step into the Red Sox
rotation, Lester was well on his way to coming back with a vengeance. After
building up his strength and stamina on a whirlwind trip through the minor
leagues, Lester dominated at AAA Pawtucket waiting for his chance to show
that he belonged back in the Majors. The Red Sox were determined not to
bring Lester back to the Show unless he was going to stay there permanently.
Injuries to Curt Schilling and the ineffectiveness of Julian Tavarez gave
Jon Lester a shot to return to the major leagues, not as a cancer victim but
as a Major League star.
The Red Sox quickly went from the best team in
baseball to stumbling over themselves as they headed into the All-Star
break. They needed something to reenergize their complacent play, and Jon
Lester returning may just be the key. The Sox have had a rather easy season,
with little pressure from any other team in the division. Seeing Jon Lester
in the clubhouse everyday is a reminder that nothing should ever be taken
for granted, in baseball or in life. Even if Lester doesn’t put up numbers
like he did last year, his contribution to the team is immeasurable. Not
since the comeback of Tony C. has a player’s return to the Sox been such an
emotional experience.
If Jon Lester can regain the form he showed last
year before the effects of cancer began to surface, the Red Sox suddenly
have a glut of young starting pitching. The Sox could have an entire
starting rotation comprised of stars all 28 years old or younger (Josh
Beckett, Dice-K, Kason Gabbard, Jon Lester, and top prospect Clay Buchholz).
Add in the ageless rubber armed Tim Wakefield, currently rehabbing Curt
Schilling, and emergency starters Julian Tavarez and Devern Hansack, and the
Sox have the deepest rotation in baseball. Add in three major league ready
outfielders in AAA Pawtucket (leadoff man of the future Jacoby Ellsbury,
David Murphy, and Brandon Moss) and the Sox have all the talent they need to
make any trade before the July 31st deadline. The Red Sox could use another
bat, some help in the bullpen, and a catcher of the future, and the Sox
could fill all of those needs without depleting the major or minor league
talent pools.
The return of Jon Lester gives the best team in
baseball more talent to work with, as well as a newfound attitude in the
clubhouse. Since Lester has rejoined the rotation the Sox are playing better
baseball, and that was without their best hitter and staff ace. The Red Sox
are in a great position to advance not only to the playoffs, but also to
their second World Series in four years. Pitching wins titles (as has been
obvious in recent years) and the Sox have the best staff in baseball this
side of
San
Diego, but with more depth. The Red Sox have only increased their grip as
the best team in baseball, all thanks to a 23 year old that was facing the
most challenging fight of his life almost exactly one year ago. Talent might
be a great thing to have but the ability to overcome adversity will carry
you through tough situations in baseball and beyond.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
HOME RUNS ARE RUINING BASEBALL
By Chris Vining May 18, 2007
One of
the most magical moments in baseball was once the home run, but as the years
pass home runs have become just a routine part of the game. Seeing a team
win without hitting at least one home run is no longer commonplace, it is
just the opposite. Teams live and die by the homer, and this trend is
helping to ruin baseball. This sentiment may make me less popular than Barry
Bonds and Tim McCarver combined, but it needs to be said. You can call me a
hypocrite, since the Red Sox have relied on the long ball for years. Home
runs fueled the Sox to the 2004 World Series victory and homers helped David
Ortiz win the last two MVP awards (neither Justin Morneau or Alex Rodriguez
were the most valuable player on their own team, let alone the league, so
their awards should be given to Ortiz). So how can I dislike home runs? All
you need to do is see how the strategy, or lack there of, in baseball has
disappeared, thus draining the intelligence out of the game.
Some players make the major leagues due to their
ability to hit home runs, and I have no problem with that. Ryan Howard is a
giant and I wouldn’t expect him to become a slap hitter trying to drop down
bunts every game. The problem I have is with players that have been
conditioned by organizations to sacrifice speed and flexibility to focus on
becoming power hitters. There are many ways to score runs in baseball and
home runs have become too large of a focus. A low level minor league player
that hits .300 with 10 home runs and 30 steals will usually be overlooked
for promotions when compared to a player that plays the same position and
hits .275 with 25 home runs and has nominal speed. Greg Maddux and Tom
Glavine were dead on when they were part of Nike’s “Chicks dig the long
ball,” add campaign. Home runs are the get rich quick scheme of baseball,
while manufacturing runs is becoming a thing of the past. Shame on baseball
for forcing strategy and small ball out of the game.
The most dangerous offensive weapon is not a home
run but the ability to force your opponent to make extra outs. Using speed,
bunting, and strategy puts pressure on the other team to play mistake free
defense (mentally as well as physically) and most teams will end up giving
away extra chances, whether it be through committing errors or being out of
position. An intelligent player can make sure he never falls into a slump,
just ask Hall of Famer Rod Carew. When Carew would start to struggle at the
plate he would drop down a few bunts, even if they ended up being foul balls
or outs. The infield would then have to reposition themselves to guard
against the bunt, thus opening up more room to hit. Paul Molitor and even
the lead-footed Wade Boggs used the bunt to their advantage. Very few
players today know how to use the bunt effectively. Most bunts outside of
the fastest players in the league (Ichiro, Juan Pierre, etc) are usually
sacrifices, and generally done by pitchers. Players need to get back to
using the bunt as a weapon, even if it is just to put the fear of the bunt
in their opponents’ head. Watching players with great speed, but no idea how
to bunt drives me crazy. Coco Crisp has spent the last two seasons in
Boston
unable to find his hitting stroke, and then attempting to beat out bunt
hits. If Crisp could lay down a bunt that didn’t go directly to an infielder
than he would be able to get on base more often, setting the table for guys
like David Ortiz or Manny Ramirez. The best player in baseball at utilizing
the bunt may just be American League home run champion David Ortiz. After
watching teams put three infielders on the right side of second base and
putting the third baseman where the shortstop usually stands against left
handed pull hitters such as Jason Giambi and Barry Bonds made me wonder why
they just didn’t drop a bunt down the third base line. If you run hard out
of the box and bunt the ball through the infield than you could possibly get
a bunt double. When teams started to use the shift against Ortiz I wondered
why he didn’t just drop down a bunt with no runners on base, just to see
what happened. Shortly after I wrote about this strategy in a column a few
years ago Ortiz began to drop down some bunts against the shift. The result
was a few foul balls, a few bunt hits, and a defense that was forced to stay
on its toes. Ortiz used the bunt to change the way teams defended pull
hitter approach, and his ability to catch the opposition flat footed
increased his value to the Red Sox.
Another myth that needs to be shot down is that you
can’t steal first base. It might not be as easy as stealing second but you
can steal first. When a player busts his ass down the line and beats out an
infield hit on a routine play that it is not only as good as stealing first,
but makes the other team work to get another out. A fast runner can cause an
infielder to rush on what would be a close play, either making the fielder
bobble the ball or throw it away. Turning an out into a runner at first is
as good as stealing first, if not even better.
While every team would love to have a roster full
of players that can hit forty homers and have blazing speed, that isn’t a
reality. Teams have to find a balance of players that can hit for power,
that can get on base and be a pest for opponents, and players that can do a
bit of everything to win. The ability to win the mental battle of baseball
is crucial for a successful team. Teams that can outthink their opponents
(as opposed to try to overpower them) and do the little things to
manufacture runs on a consistent basis will be the teams that are the most
likely to walk away with a World Series trophy come November.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
2007 BASEBALL AWARDS PREDICTIONS
By Chris Vining March 30, 2007
Now
that spring has finally started to emerge it means that the real baseball
season is about to start. The slate will be wiped clean for those players
struggling so far this season, but are hot starts a signal of success of
what may lay ahead? Each year players come out of nowhere to surprise fans
and journalists alike. On the flip side, talented players see their careers
go down the drain due to injuries, age, or ineffectiveness. So which players
will take home baseball’s hardware this year, and which players will land on
hard times? Only time will tell, but here are my fool proof (or ish) picks.
AMERICAN LEAGUE
Cy Young – Johan Santana might be the best
pitcher in baseball, but his contract demands might have put a wedge into
the team first Twins. While Santana will have a good season his contract
issues will be a story all year, and he won’t repeat as Cy Young. Roy
Halladay is a workhorse that is always in the running, and he has recovered
from injuries late last year. Mike Mussina is a stellar pitcher on a great
team, and uncertainties with the Yankees rotation make him the go to guy.
Ervin Santana is a future star that looks like he will become an ace for the
Angels. C.C. Sabathia has all the tools to become one of the best lefties in
baseball; he only needs to grow up. Curt Schilling talks a good game and may
have one last magical run left in his arm. Winner –
Scott
Kazmir Tampa Bay. Here me out on this one. Kaz is the best young lefty in
baseball, he has already been a major league ace for almost two seasons
despite just turning 23. The Devil Rays have one of the best outfields in
baseball, and a wealth of young talent. Kaz missed part of the second half
of last year with a sore shoulder but his stats would have projected to
15-12 with an ERA of just over 3, and 240 strikeouts in just over 200
innings. Don’t be shocked to see him duplicate the one-man rotation
performance that Randy Johnson posted with the Diamondbacks a half dozen
years ago.
MVP – Carl Crawford, Vernon Wells, and Grady
Sizemore are all MVP quality players stuck in small market hell (see
Beltran, Carlos Kansas City Royals). Travis Hafner is a great hitter than is
now stuck with the “DH only” label that will prevent him from winning an
MVP. Arod has the stats and skills to win another MVP but has too large and
frail of an ego to win another MVP. Derek Jeter deserves a lifetime MVP
award but his importance isn’t measured just by stats, but also by
leadership and intangibles. Justin Morneau should hide his MVP because his
win last year seemed like an episode of Punk’d without Ashton Kutcher taking
back the award. Manny Ramirez’s defensive shortcomings and mental tomfoolery
will prevent him from winning an MVP. Ichiro lacks the power to win over the
voters despite being on a level with Jeter in terms of value to his team.
Winner – David Ortiz Red Sox. This is the year for Big Papi. He will
play enough in the field to squash the “DH only “debate, he has a better
lineup with JD Drew and Julio Lugo, as well as the best protection in
baseball in Manny Ramirez. There is no player in baseball that can deliver
like Ortiz and this is the year that he will be rewarded for his efforts.
ROY
– Is there really even a need to discuss this? Alex Gordon and Delmon Young
might have great careers ahead of them but they picked the wrong year to be
a rookie. Daisuke Matsuzaka is not only the best rookie in baseball this
year, he could also challenge for the Cy Young. DiceK reminds me of Pedro
Martinez when he was pitching in Montreal. He has a ton of talent, great
natural ability, but just needs a bit of polishing around the edges. By the
time his first contract expires after the 2011 season, DiceK will have more
hardware on his mantle than U2.
Comeback Player – Mike Maroth is a quality
starter that could be crucial for the Tigers to make a repeat trip to the
World Series. Sammy Sosa looks like his year off was for the best, as he has
gone from outcast to a key member of a team with playoff goals. Sosa could
easily hit 25 home runs in a hitter’s park. If Eric Gagne can make it
through the season without his arm flying off than that will be a miracle.
Winner - Gary Sheffield
Detroit. One of the best offseason moves was the Tigers trading for
Sheffield, a power hitter that suddenly became expendable for the Yankees.
Expect the trade of Doc’s nephew to burn the Yankees come playoff time.
Biggest Disappointment – Gil Meche is in an
impossible situation. He is an average pitcher (a number 3 starter at best)
who was given eight figures a year to be the ace of the worst team in
baseball. Meche would have been a good signing at half the price, but there
is no way Meche can even come close to pitching well enough to justify his
contract.
NATIONAL LEGAUE
Cy Young – The National League lacks a true
dominant pitcher; even the Cy Young winner would have trouble cracking the
top five in the American League. You have the fading veterans like John
Smoltz, Jason Schmidt, and Tom Glavine that are on their last legs. There
are always the injury risks such as John Patterson, Chris Carpenter, and
Jake Peavy. What is left over are the pitchers that have talent but haven’t
been able to completely refine their game over a complete season, defacto
aces like Dontrelle Willis and Carlos Zambrano. So who is left? A great
pitcher on a poor team in Brandon Webb, an All-Star pitcher attempting to
switch leagues in Barry Zito, and a good pitcher on a solid team. That
pitcher will win the Cy Young because, well, someone has to…Congratulations
to
Roy
Oswalt the 2007 NL Cy Young.
MVP – Baseball just isn’t fair and the MVP
race proves that very fact. Talented small market players are often
overlooked despite immense talent.
Jason
Bay and Miguel Cabrera have the misfortune of playing for the wrong team at
the wrong time. Lance Berkman and Andruw Jones have skills but fail to grab
headlines. David Wright and Chase Utley are up and coming stars that play
second fiddle to teammates that can put up gaudy stats. Alfonso Soriano is a
five-tool player but moving from team to team and position to position (in
the field and in the batting order) doesn’t do him any favors. Albert Pujols
and Ryan Howard are the best power hitters in the National League and will
both be multiple time MVPs before their careers are done. None of these
deserving players will take home the hardware this year, that distinction
goes to a player with the least amount of power amongst the MVP candidates.
Winner - Jose Reyes New York Mets. Reyes could lead the league in
hits, runs, batting average, stolen bases, triples, and on base percentage.
Reyes is the fuel that makes the Mets run and is the catalyst to one of the
best teams in baseball. Reyes is entering his fifth season and will only
turn 24 this year. His best is yet to come.
ROY
– Kevin Kouzmanoff looks like the real deal for the Padres, and the recent
release of Todd Walker gives him a spot as a starter at third base. Chris
Young looks to have the Diamondback’s center field job nailed down and could
impress on a young team. Homer Bailey will start the season in the minors
but with the Red’s rotation (or lack there of) Bailey could be in the
rotation by May. Chris Iannetta looks to be the Rockies catcher of the
future, with the future possibly coming this year. Andy LaRoche stands a
good chance to get a lot of playing time for the Dodgers, but putting a
young player’s future in Grady Little’s hands isn’t a smart idea. Troy
Tulowitzki won the Rockies starting shortstop job but will have Clint Barnes
breathing down his neck. Winner - Mike Pelfrey New York Mets. A good
pitcher on a great team that will have a lot of run support. The National
League ROY race looks weak as several key candidates have been send down to
the minors.
Comeback Player – Derrek Lee and Todd Helton
will not only battle for the rights to be the third best first basemen in
the National League behind Albert Pujols and Ryan Howard, they will also
battle for Comeback Player of the Year. Both men are Triple Crown threats if
they can stay healthy, but Lee has a much more experienced lineup around him
to take off some of the pressure. Helton also has to deal with the
speculation of constant trade rumors and inexperienced players around him.
Both men have all the talent to win an MVP award, but other talented players
at their position overshadow both.
Biggest Disappointment – Carlos Lee is a
great player in a hitter’s park but was greatly overpaid this offseason by
Houston. I wouldn’t be surprised to see him easily pass thirty home runs
this year, but I also wouldn’t be surprised to see him balloon to 350 pounds
eating Texas barbeque and end up needing gastric bypass surgery by the trade
deadline. Grady Little also getting a contract extension through 2009 (club
option) might be the worst off the field move since Pete Rose was named
manager of the Reds.
Under no circumstances do I expect all of these
predictions to come true. No matter how well you think you know baseball,
some player will come out of nowhere and set the world on fire, and at least
one star player will crash and burn. Come September it will be obvious who
those players are, but at this time it is all just an educated guess.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
FANTASY BASEBALL SURVIVAL GUIDE
By Chris Vining March 15, 2007
Nothing says “spring” like fantasy baseball. I am a certified expert,
playing before I even knew what fantasy baseball was. When I was six I
progressed from just watching baseball to studying the stats during the
games, from the writers in the paper, and on television. I became engrossed
in the game of baseball, the science, the moves of managers, how players
positioned themselves, the nuisances most people overlook or simply never
knew existed. By age twelve I started drafting expansion teams and charting
the stats through the season. Once I got internet access I was involved in
sometimes a dozen leagues a year, testing different strategies, theories,
all to give you the knowledge on how to be a success in any baseball league.
Every year, no matter how many leagues I have been in, I have finished first
more than any other position. Keep in mind one important thing; even if you
follow these ideas the players you draft and moves you make (and teams make)
can cause a great team on draft day to crash and burn.
Know the layout of your league – Your draft
depends on the makeup of your league, the number of teams, the scoring
system, size of roster, etc. This is the most important thing about your
draft.
Memorial Day – You can't win your league
before Memorial Day but you can lose it. You should make your move to the
top of the standings in your league in May. This is the key month. You can
fall too far out of contention and start to make rash decisions if you get
panicked. By this time the slow starters should be coming around and helping
you rise in the standings. The fast starters that had a hot April will now
have forced your competitors down in the standings. Players will now round
into shape and will be showing their true colors. This is the time to figure
out where have holes and how to address them.
Draft the toughest positions first – There
is a big drop off between the elite catchers, shortstops, and second basemen
and the average ones. Positions like first base are extremely deep so you
can wait a few rounds and still get a top-notch talent. Pick up the middle
first. There are about a half dozen players at each position that will help
you win, and if you miss out one those players than your team will be
starting in a hole.
Multiple Position Players – Any time you can
get a player that is eligible at multiple positions, take him. You can never
have enough depth against injuries or ineffective players, but a player who
can play four positions will help you fill the gap. You then have four
position options to find a replacement instead of just one. (Ex. Ryan Freel
can play second, third, and outfield in most leagues. If he is on your bench
you can put him in any of those four spots and find another player from the
waiver wire or through trades. Multiple positions = Multiple options)
Don't get sentimental – You may like to get
players from your favorite team but you will be more likely to overvalue
them both during the draft and during the season. It may be great to have
your favorite player but it will be harder to be objective if they struggle
or if they are offered in trades.
Sophomore Players – Or as I like to call
them, the Black Death. The better the rookie season a player has the higher
the expectation is for their second season. Most players slip in their
second season, not just off of expectations, but off of their rookie season
stats. There is generally one exception to the rule every year, but don't
take the risk unless it is a player like Albert Pujols. Look at a few of the
recent MLB ROY’s. Bobby Crosby, injured most of his second season. Angel
Berroa, barely good enough to play for the Royals. Rafael Furcal, torn
hamstring and missed time. Even Dontrelle Willis struggled in his second
season.
Huston
Street looked like the safe bet last year but he was injured. Stay away from
Justin Verlander and the entire Marlins rotation.
Defense means nothing – Ozzie Smith was a
first ballot Hall of Famer, but it wasn't because of his bat. Great
defensive players won't help you unless your league penalizes you for
errors. The one exception is for Interleague games, where poor defensive
players might not see as much time as they would normally.
Fast starters vs. Slow Starters - Some
players are known as fast starters and others are slow starters. Draft a
fast starter for your bench to trade before he starts to cool off. Also look
for slow starters to watch and when they start to get hot, grab them via
trade or off waivers.
Focus on great teams – Every team might have
at least one All-Star but playoff teams win for a reason. You are more
likely to have a pitcher get a win or no decision instead of a loss if he
plays on a team with great offense.
Never ignore the bullpen workhorse - They
tend to get decisions out of the bullpen, as well as an occasional start or
save. These players pitch every other day, will pick up wins, the occasional
save, and usually give you a good ERA and WHIP.
Don't forget players who will be changing
positions – Many players change positions in the off-season; they just
may not be eligible to start the season. Be patient because by mid-April
they will be eligible at multiple positions.
Be careful of rookies – Most rookies are
over hyped, and don't live up to expectations. Look for decent rookies after
the first 6-8 weeks who may see increased time as the season.
Ignore Spring Training stats – Spring
training stats mean nothing in most cases. Unless a player gets hurt and
opens a spot for someone you wouldn't have considered, forget about good
spring training starts.
This is my advice on how to win in any league. Take
the advice of an expert who has a stack of trophies and has spent years
trying to find the perfect fantasy formula. If you want advice on who to
draft, don't ask. Each person has players that they like or feel strongly
about, and I don't want the responsibility if your #2 starter tanks. If you
would like me to take part in your league feel free to email me, I can
always use another trophy.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
ANOTHER MANNY SPRING
By Chris Vining February 21, 2007
A superstar athlete
reporting to training camp or spring training after the due date is hardly
news. These days if an athlete reported early (unless he was in a contract
year) that would be the stuff of headlines. Superstars have become so jaded
that they think the rules or the law don’t apply to them. If an athlete is
being given top dollar than they should set an example and behave, not
exploit what they have given. Maybe years of pressure and work make someone
think they can set their own rules, but that doesn’t fly in the real world.
Now that the after school special part of the
column is over, it is time to talk about the prime offender of the slacker
athlete, Manny Ramirez. Being a Red Sox fan has made me slightly bias
towards Manny. He is great on the field, a pain in the posterior off the
field. This year is the perfect example. Julian Tavarez alerted the
Boston media that Manny
wouldn’t be reporting to spring training on time, a fact that shouldn’t
shock any Red Sox fan. The reason for Manny’s tardiness is a bit surprising;
he is caring for his mother who is recovering from having a cancerous tumor
removed from her ribs. I wish her well, and I am not questioning that Manny
is concerned about his mother. However, if Manny was my child I would rather
he spring for a nurse than take care of me himself.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
A FICKLE NATION
By Chris Vining January 30, 2007
For the
first time in years I am truly disappointed in Red Sox fans. It turns out
that winning the World Series wasn’t enough; we want to win that trophy
every year. Not only do we expect the Sox to win, we are appalled if the
franchise gives us even the slightest sign that the organization might not
be willing to win at all costs. Fans demand a championship caliber team in
Boston and a farm system filled with so many prospects that there aren’t
enough places for them to play. Red Sox fans have become hypocrites. This
off-season, with a few moves in particular, has proven that there is no way
to satisfy Red Sox Nation.
Fans in
Boston
were ecstatic when the Red Sox were trying to win the rights to negotiate
with Daisuke Matsuzaka. Once it was revealed that the team paid over
fifty-one million dollars just to earn the right to talk to him, the common
sentiment was that the management at Yawkey Way had lost its marbles. The
longer the negotiations dragged on the more enraged the fans became. This
outrage lasted right up until Dice-K was signed, sealed, and delivered. At
that point the sentiment changed. The Sox brass were now geniuses for
getting a top of the rotation starter without having to give up any
prospects, and for spending less money than other top starters were getting.
(You will notice the start of a pattern developing here)
Last year the weak spot in the
Boston
lineup was the 5th spot, and right field was a disaster area. Willy Mo Pena
couldn’t play defense and Trot Nixon couldn’t hit when he was healthy. A
major upgrade was needed and the Sox targeted the best option on the market,
JD Drew. Drew has his share of issues (injuries and attitude) but is an
All-Star when he is healthy. Most people seem to agree that five years and
seventy million dollars is too much money and too long of a contract, and I
don’t disagree. Drew is better when he is playing for a contract, but there
was no way he was going to opt out of a three year deal worth eleven million
a year for a one year contract. The Drew signing has been widely criticized,
but that is no surprise. It wasn’t until Trot Nixon signed in Cleveland that
the fans seemed to warm up to Drew. It is amazing how quickly people will
warm up to someone when there is no other option. The Sox have David Murphy
and Pena that could have played right field, but these were inadequate
options. Murphy was too good to be traded to Florida to be their starting
center fielder, but he isn’t good enough to even platoon with Pena. That
makes no sense, as Pena has shown flashes of brilliance at the plate, and
Murphy looked impressive (albeit briefly) even before adding 15 pounds of
muscle in the off-season.
The latest mess has centered on the potential trade
for Todd Helton. The
Rockies
were looking to swap Helton for Mike Lowell, Julian Tavarez, Manny
Delcarmen, and Craig Hansen. Helton has six years left on his contract worth
approximately ninety million dollars, and the Rockies were willing to pay
close to two-thirds of the remaining balance. However, a report in the
Boston Globe today indicates that Colorado was only willing to pay a third
of that total cost (Globe
Link). Helton is one of the few professional hitters in baseball,
in the lines of a Tony Gwynn, Mark Grace, or Derek Jeter. Helton struggled
last year due to an intestinal infection that left him hospitalized and took
away his strength. Helton is fully cured and back to 100%. When he is
healthy Helton is a threat to win a batting title, as well as put up 30 home
runs and 100 RBIs. Before you jump to the Coors Field inflated stats
argument, remember that Helton put up similar numbers on the road as he did
at home. Helton isn’t the type of player that needed high altitude to put up
amazing stats.
Why were Red Sox fans so negative towards this
trade? I truly wish I knew because this is a mystery to me. Fans were
calling for Theo Epstein’s job if he made this trade. Mike Lowell is a Gold
Glove caliber third baseman with one year left on his contract for about
nine million dollars. Helton would step in at first and move Kevin Youkilis
back to his natural position of third base. Both Lowell and Youkilis are
.280-.300 hitters with the ability to hit close to twenty home runs a year.
Lowell
might be a bit better defensively, but Youk is an on-base machine, is much
younger, cheaper, and a better value. Even straight up Youkilis (the Greek
god of walks) is better than Lowell.
The issue could lay in the Red Sox unsettled
bullpen. Julian Tavarez finished last year in impressive fashion as a long
reliever and occasional starter. Tavarez is a bulldog with the proper
mentality for a closer. The irony is that Tavarez was so awful for the first
two thirds of the season that fans were begging for his release. Tavarez is
in his thirties; he isn’t a kid who just suddenly found his game. Tavarez is
shaky and not a crucial component to this team. Manny Delcarmen is a solid
young middle reliever, but not the closer type. Delcarmen is a local kid who
has career middle reliever written all over him. He has shown flashes of
talent, but has also struggled with his command and mound presence. He is an
asset but is far from untouchable. That leaves us with the deal breaker, the
Red Sox 2005 first round draft pick, Craig Hansen.
Hansen was an All-American closer at
Saint
Johns’s University, and has been on the fast track to major league
greatness. After the 2005 draft Peter Gammons even said that Hansen would
probably be an All-Star closer this year. A funny thing happened along the
way, the Red Sox screwed up Hansen, possibly beyond repair. He was rushed to
the majors and struggled in 2005. He did gain valuable experience and was
expected to be a key member of the 2006 bullpen. Keith Foulke and Jon
Papelbon battled for the closer job early in the season and Hansen struggled
just to stay in the majors. When the former starter Papelbon emerged as a
dominant closer the Sox decided to try to experiment with making Hansen a
starter. Hansen was stretched out in AAA Pawtucket, where it became apparent
that he didn’t have the repertoire to be a starter. Hansen came back up to
Boston as a reliever but he lacked confidence. His promise seemed to be a
thing of the past. Hansen looked like another nameless faceless middle
reliever, not the closer of the future. Has Hansen been permanently damaged?
Only time will tell, but his stock has dropped dramatically.
At this point it looks like Todd Helton will remain
in
Colorado, and the Red Sox bullpen will consist of a dozen arms battling for
half a dozen spots. This trade could have put the Red Sox over the top and
given them one of the best offenses in baseball, all without taking much
away from the overall team. Swapping a few young guys and some replaceable
veterans for an All-Star seems like a no-brainer to me. For the rest of Red
Sox Nation this deal seemed like the worst idea since swapping a AA third
baseman named Bagwell for a quality middle reliever to help in the playoff
stretch run. This is the problem with Red Sox fans; we want an organization
that will do whatever it takes to win, but just as long as we don’t have to
invest too much into a contract or trade. We want to keep our prospects and
still trade for superstars without giving up anything valuable. The sheer
lack of gray matter amongst Sox fans is astounding. A team needs to build up
the farm system to have young players to replace veterans and to use in
trades. Money needs to be spent to attract and retain top talent. Trades
need to be made to obtain missing pieces, even if it involves some risk. The
reaction to this off-season (and the Helton trade in general) has made me
ashamed to be a Red Sox fan. I never realized or expected that the Sox fans
would be the laughing stock of baseball, a group of spoiled whiners that
have lost touch with what it takes to build a winning team. You can go ahead
and hate me for telling the truth, but maybe the only way fans will listen
is if they are hearing this news from one of their own. Go Sox, the World
Series awaits, no matter what you have to do to get there or how long it
takes.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
DREW WILL STEP INTO A TOUGH SPOT
By Chris Vining January 22, 2007
It
became official on Friday; the Boston Red Sox will have a new right fielder
this season. JD Drew officially signed…just kidding. Trot Nixon did sign
however, joining former teammates Keith Foulke and Eric Wedge in Cleveland.
While Nixon is no longer the borderline star he once was, he is the type of
player that any team would want. Nobody plays with more tenacity and drive
than Nixon, and his recent injury history proves that point. Nixon played
too hard for his own good, willing to sacrifice his body for weeks at a time
in an attempt to make a single out. You can’t teach players to play with a
“balls to the wall” attitude, either that mindset is present or it’s not.
Nixon might only be in his early thirties, but his body is broken down from
his style of play. Trot will never be able to be an every day player, and
will most likely be out of baseball due to injuries before the end of the
decade.
With that being said, Nixon will be almost
impossible to replace. He was a great motivator and had the respect of his
teammates. The Red Sox lineup will seem somewhat empty without number seven
next year, but this will be for the best. If the Sox want to see the World
Series then they need to set their focus on finalizing the contract with JD
Drew.
The biggest problems with the Red Sox last year may
have been injuries, but having the worst production in all of baseball from
the fifth spot in the lineup was the second largest problem. The fifth spot
in the lineup was a virtual abyss last year, no matter who batted there was
doomed to fall into a slump that was impossible to climb out of. It didn’t
matter if it was Nixon, Jason Varitek, Mike Lowell, Willy Mo Pena, Kevin
Youkilis, Jim Rice, or even myself batting fifth: Everyone failed. (A little
known fact is that at the end of the year Jim Rice un-retired for one game
and batted fifth. He went one for three with a single, and then I pinch ran
for him. I struck out and walked, but it was still the fifteenth most
productive game out of the five hole last year.)
The Sox had one of the five worst statistical
productions from the number five hitter last year in all of the following
categories: Batting average, hits, extra base hits, home runs, runs batted
in, walks, on base percentage, and slugging percentage. It is astounding
that a team that was in the playoff hunt for almost the entire year could do
so poorly at such a crucial position. This is why the Red Sox need JD Drew.
He can hit for average, he has above average power, can drive in runs, and
has a very selective eye at the plate. This is why the Red Sox need Drew,
but there is seventy million reasons why signing Drew could possibly be a
huge mistake.
Very few people in baseball are fans of JD Drew.
Drew is known as a malcontent, a whiner, and as being soft when it comes to
injuries. In nine years Drew has had five hundred at bats only once, and
that was three years ago (and in a contract year). When Drew is happy he can
be an All-Star caliber player, however Drew is not exactly full of smiles
and giggles. Drew tends to be a bit of a mercenary, caring more about
himself and his financial situation than what is happening on the team
footing the bill for his services. JD Drew is the type of player that is at
his best when he is playing for something, a new contract for example. Drew
has no history of being a team first player; he is Manny Ramirez without the
clinical insanity. A healthy and motivated Drew would be worth fifteen
million dollars a year, but give him a five year deal and you won’t see that
Drew consistently.
When the Red Sox finally sign JD Drew (and they
will once a contract with the proper medical insurances is completed) they
will get a stellar defensive right fielder. This will be key since right
field at
Fenway Park is tough
(just ask Willy Mo Pena) and the Red Sox rotation consists of mostly fly
ball pitchers. Drew should be able to hit close to .280 with twenty-five
home runs and at least eighty runs batted in, assuming he can play one
hundred and forty games. Drew also gives the Sox a left-handed bat behind
David Ortiz and Manny Ramirez, creating a lefty-righty-lefty situation, very
beneficial for late in games. There are many advantages to having Drew in a
Red Sox lineup, but five years is much too long for a player with his
history. The Red Sox have Willy Mo Pena looking for regular at bats, as well
as David Murphy, Brandon Moss, and Jacoby Ellsbury all looking like they
will be ready to be starters by 2009 if not sooner.
The only reason Drew was given a five year deal was
because he was willing to opt out of a guaranteed deal for three years and
close to thirty-three million dollars. He was “rewarded” with two extra
years by the Red Sox. Call it collusion if you want, it was a smart deal by
Drew and his agent Scott Boras. Drew could be useful in
Boston for two maybe three years before he starts to be a financial anchor
that blocks the path of more talented, younger, cheaper, and healthier
players. The Red Sox are doing the right thing for their franchise by
signing JD Drew, and hopefully a playoff birth and World Series title will
follow. Sox fans can only hope that by 2010 Drew will be able to have his
contract voided and sent packing. Cleveland will be looking for a right
fielder to replace Trot Nixon by then.
You can comment on this and other "Guest Columns" by going to the message board. A thread for this and other "Guest Columns" has already been established and is waiting for your commentary in the members only section of the message board. Also check out Chris Vining's blog "The Sports Punk"
| Interactive |
| Message Board |
| UOTM Radio |
| Site Columns & Features |
| Blog |
| Obstructed View |
| Weekly Prospects Harvest |
| Gap Shots & Gopher Balls |
| From The Cheap Seats |
| Sports OverReAction Desk |
| The Interview Room |
| Focus On The Past |
| Red Sox Hall of Fame |
| Red Sox Record book |
| Photos From Members |
| Red Sox Information |
| Official MLB Site |
| Pawtucket "AAA" Site |
| Portland "AA" Site |
| Lancaster (CA) "A" Site |
| Greenville (SC) "A" Site |
| Lowell "A" Site |
|
TICKET CENTER |
|
Razorgator.com |
|
Purchase Up On The Monster @ StubHub.com |
|
Go Tickets Red Sox Tickets Brewers Tickets Mets Tickets Angels Tickets Indians Tickets |
| Get Your Red Sox Headlines |
| The Boston Globe |
| The Boston Herald |
| The Providence Journal |
| The Eagle Tribune |
| The Hartford Courant |